It looks like China does have access to U.S. TikTok user data

TikTok logo

UPDATE: Nov. 3, 2022, 11:31 a.m. EDT This article has been updated to reflect new information confirming suspicions about China's access to U.S. and European user data.

Despite the repeated assurances that TikTok's parent company, the China-based ByteDance, isn't checking out data collected about users in the U.S. and Europe, it looks like the company absolutely does and can.

According a report from The Guardian on Wednesday, TikTok’s head of privacy in Europe, Elaine Fox, told employees: "Based on a demonstrated need to do their job, subject to a series of robust security controls and approval protocols, and by way of methods that are recognized [sp] under the GDPR, we allow certain employees within our corporate group located in Brazil, Canada, China, Israel, Japan, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore, South Korea, and the United States, remote access to TikTok European user data."

We already knew that TikTok employees based in China can see U.S. data. On July 1, TikTok confirmed that employees based in China are able to access U.S. user data through "approval protocols." According to the New York Times, TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew provided details about how it plans to keep data about its American users separate from ByteDance, its Chinese parent company, in a letter to nine Republican senators. In that letter, he noted that ByteDance employees in China were able to access TikTok data only through “subject to a series of robust cybersecurity controls and authorization approval protocols overseen by our U.S.-based security team.” Chew added, “We know we are among the most scrutinized platforms from a security standpoint, and we aim to remove any doubt about the security of U.S. user data."

The nine Republican senators write to TikTok with questions about its practices after a Jun. 17 from BuzzFeed News in which they reviewed recordings containing over a dozen separate statements from nine different TikTok employees showed that engineers in China had access to U.S. data from at least September 2021 through January 2022. One member of TikTok’s Trust and Safety department said, in September 2021, that "everything is seen in China," according to BuzzFeed News. Apparently, there's even one Beijing-based engineer who "has access to everything" — they call them a "Master Admin."

That means former President Donald Trump may have been correct in his assessment of the app when he said in an August 2020 executive order that TikTok's "data collection threatens to allow" China to "access to Americans’ personal and proprietary information." TikTok repeatedly said it has never and would never share U.S. user data with the Chinese government.

In response to BuzzFeed News' investigation, a TikTok spokesperson said the app is "among the most scrutinized platforms from a security standpoint" and that it plans to "remove any doubt about the security of U.S. user data."

TikTok has already come under fire for its data collection, and this is just another step in yet another app collecting information on its users and doing whatever it pleases with it. It seems being online in 2022 is becoming more and more difficult to do while maintaining some semblance of privacy and data autonomy.

Multiple Fitbit trackers are on sale for their lowest prices ever

A woman with the Fitbit Sense 2 on her wrist

Looking to pick up a new fitness tracker? Check out these Fitbit deals, available as of Nov. 3:

  • OUR TOP PICK: The Fitbit Sense 2 is a full-featured, affordable alternative to the Apple Watch with heart rate, temperature, and atrial fibrillation sensors — $199.95 $299.95 (save $100)

  • BEST VALUE: The Fitbit Luxe is a solid, versatile option with a sleek design and fitness tracking essentials — $79.95 $129.95 (save $50)


When it comes to fitness trackers, the Apple Watch is hardly the only notable model. Fitbit's expansive product line offers a slew of great features at typically affordable prices.

The Fitbit Sense line has historically been a bit on the pricier side, and that hasn't changed with its most recent launch, the Sense 2, which just debuted in August. If you've had your eye on one of the brand's newest releases and can't wait for the holidays to bring discounts on trackers across the board, this early Black Friday sale is a great time to grab one.

As of Nov. 3, you can head to Amazon to pick up the Fitbit Sense 2 for 33% off (just $199.95) — and the great-looking, dressier Fitbit Luxe for 38% off ($79.95), both currently sitting at their lowest respective prices.

Not sure which model fits your needs? Here are both Fitbit models on offer at Amazon and Fitbit for their lowest prices ever.

Our top pick

Why we like it

Launched in Aug. 2022, the Fitbit Sense 2 is one of Fitbit's newest trackers. In addition to a larger display and tons of health tracking capabilities, it includes an all-day "Body Response" sensor to help with managing stress — a harder-to-find component in most fitness wearables. It also includes a full laundry list of tracking tools, including 24/7 heart rate monitoring, sleep and workout tracking, Active Zone Minutes, and up to six days of battery life.

Snag it at Amazon or Fitbit in select colors for just $199.95 — that's 33% off its $299.95 MSRP and its lowest price ever.

Best value

Why we like it

The fashion-forward Fitbit Luxe is one of the best-looking fitness trackers around. But don't judge a book by its cover, as it's more than just a pretty face. It offers 24/7 heart rate monitoring, menstrual and sleep tracking, step counting, stress management scoring, and two dozen exercise modes, with up to five days of battery life. Unlike the Fitbit Sense 2, it doesn't include phone and text functionality, but this budget-friendly pick does offer a subscription to Fitbit Premium for $9.99/month that unlocks advanced metrics that bring it more in line with Fitbit's other offerings.

Grab one at Amazon or Fitbit in multiple colors for just $79.95 — that's 38% off its $129.95 MSRP and its lowest price ever.

The best gifts for men: Creative ideas for every type of guy

Collage of products from Hydro Flask, Polaroid, Felix gray, Kindle, and Lodge.

No two guys are the same, and not every man spends their days dreaming of whiskey stones. (In fact, we'd guess that very few of them do.) Traditional male stereotypes are a thing of the past, y'all, and it's time we started embracing that fact when we're looking for gifts.

Before you click “buy” on something that will definitely require a gift receipt, let us take the wheel and show you some options that are sure to make an impression on whomever that lucky guy is. (Need more specific gift ideas? Check out this gift guide for the father figure in your life, or this one if you’re shopping for your boyfriend.)

Whether he’s into kitchen accessories, fashion-forward athleisure, self-care products, or something more eccentric, we’re confident that he'll love the picks on this list.

The best early Black Friday pet deals to help you treat your furry friend

Dog with smart collar eating kibble

UPDATE: Nov. 3, 2022, 3:00 p.m. EDT This list has been updated to reflect pricing and availability as of Nov. 3.


Holiday shopping is all about buying gifts for your loved ones, and if your loved ones happen to be cats or dogs, you're in luck. This upcoming Black Friday, we plan on seeing tons of great pet deals, so you'll be able to spoil your furry friend for a bargain this year.

We've already spotted some solid discounts on smart collars, DNA kits, and more, so expect to see lots more pet tech deals as the Black Friday season ramps up. Find all those deals and more below, and be sure to check back on this page often — we'll be updating it regularly with new discounts.

Please note: All newly added deals have been marked with a . Anything with a strikeout was either sold out or no longer available at the sale price as of this writing, but check back often — we're updating this page constantly.

Pet tech deals

Why we love it

Whistle's smart collars all pack in a ton of helpful features, and the Switch is no different. You'll get access to Whistle Health, which allows you to track your pet's health stats and behaviors, as well as accurate GPS services with the ability to mark safe zones. Rest easy knowing that your four-legged bestie is in safe hands.

More pet tech on sale

Pet DNA kit deals

Why we love it

If you want to be more connected to your pet, a DNA kit is a great way to do just that. The Wisdom Panel Premium kit will give you accurate breed testing across over 350 breeds, 210 health tests for genetic risks, and can even help you find your pup's biological family.

More pet DNA kits on sale

Pet bed deals

Why we love it

Let's say you want your dog to be cozy, but you also want their bed to match your stylish home decor. Checking both boxes might sound like a far-off dream, but Paw.com's rug beds actually fit the bill. With a removable, washable cover, memory foam inner, and a design that's meant to look like a decorative rug, these beds are the all-in-one pet product you've been looking for. You can also score up to 50% off nearly every bed on the site ahead of Black Friday.

More pet beds on sale

Deals on pet toys and accessories

Why we love it

If you have a genius dog on your hands, a puzzle toy is one of the best ways to release some of that mental energy. This well-rated Nina Ottosson toy has multiple compartments that hold treats, and your pup will learn to flip, slide, and lift the pieces to reveal their snacks. It's sure to keep boredom at bay, so you can get some work done while your dog plays.

More pet toys and accessories on sale

Google recognizes Native American Heritage Month with new interactive features

Google recognizes Native American Heritage Month with new interactive features

A screenshot of a red Google Chrome homepage. The art behind the search bar shows two white birds drawn in a particular artistic style using curved lines.

As November ushers in Native American Heritage Month, even your virtual assistants are joining in the nationwide celebration of Indigenous culture.

A new Google Assistant feature lets users hear from first-hand interviews with members of Indigenous communities as they reflect on their cultural experiences. After waking up your Assistant, say "Tell me a human story" and your device will play the voices of people like Nanieezh, a girl sharing what it means to be Native American.

Users will also be able to access a collection of Native American Heritage facts via Google Assistant, focused on important cultural moments and leaders in Native American history. To hear your daily fact, users just need to say, “Happy Native American Heritage Month'' or “Give me a fact about Native American Heritage."

In addition, Google Chrome and ChromeOS unveiled new themes for users, designed by a cohort of five Native American artists.

"Hey, Google! Happy Native American Heritage Month."

Blair Huffman, group product manager for ChromeOS and member of the Cherokee Nation, wrote in a Google blog post that the new themes showcases important traditions and highlights the artists' unique experiences and identities.

"As a citizen of the Cherokee Nation, I celebrate this month by taking time to reflect and express gratitude for my ancestors, the resilience of my tribe and other Indigenous people, and future generations carrying our tribal traditions forward," Huffman wrote. "Richard D. York’s piece 'ᎤᎧᏖᎾ (Uktena, or 'Horned Serpent')' in particular brings me back to my childhood listening to the stories of Uktena and other tales from my elders. A more solemn work, 'A Lot Meant,' reminded me of growing up in Oklahoma and how historical policies like allotment impacted my family and so many others."

A screenshot of the Google Chrome homepage, with one of the new custom themes applied. The art behind the search bar is an abstract wash of various colors and shapes.
Another theme, titled "ᎤᎧᏖᎾ (Horned Serpent)”, depicts a malevolent dragon present in Cherokee stories. It was created by artist Richard D. York. Credit: Richard D. York / Google
Three birds (one blue, one green, and one red) are drawn flying over a color-blocked landscape. A bright white crescent moon is behind them.
One of the new themes titled "Primary Ravens". It was created by artist Crystal Worl. Credit: Crystal Worl / Google

This month's updates follow previous initiatives by Google and Google Assistant, including voice features that taught users important aspects of Black history and civil rights in honor of Juneteenth, as well as interactive personal health support in honor of Breast Cancer Awareness Month.

Google launched its recognition of Native American Heritage Month on Nov. 1, with a Google Doodle celebrating Indigenous North American stickball. The ceremonial game has its history in several Native American communities, including the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Seminole, and Yuchi tribes. The celebratory Doodle was created by artist Marlena Myles, a member of the Spirit Lake Dakota / Mohegan / Muscogee tribe. "This sport has played an active role through the generations in our many tribes and it will continue to do so," Myles wrote. "We’re keeping traditions alive."

Just ask Google: "Tell me a human story."

The new features allow all users to engage with the stories, art, and history of our country's Indigenous communities, so use your Google devices as a starting point for a deeper exploration of this vast and varied heritage. All it takes to begin is a simple "Hey, Google..."

<div>‘God of War Ragnarok’ plays it safe by playing the hits</div>

‘God of War Ragnarok’ plays it safe by playing the hits

God of War Ragnarok screenshot

Warning: This review contains spoilers for the 2018 God of War game as well as some elements of God of War Ragnarok.

Never before have I played a game for which the phrase “if you liked the last one, you’ll like this one” applies as much as it does with God of War Ragnarok.

When Sony rebooted God of War in 2018, the whole conceit seemed comical. You’re telling me Kratos, the most heinously angry man in the history of video game fiction, has now suddenly become an emo dad who regrets killing off the entire Greek pantheon of gods... and I’m supposed to be touched by that?

Shockingly, that approach worked for a lot of people, even if I was less impressed by it myself. God of War 2018 was high on many Game of the Year lists, sold 23 million copies, and is generally regarded as one of the best PlayStation 4 games. And while I never forged an emotional bond with Kratos and his young son Atreus, I was still drawn in by its visual splendor, surprisingly deep combat, and massive set-piece boss battles.

You could copy and paste that last sentence and it would apply to the sequel, out Nov. 8 on PlayStation 4 and 5. Sony’s Santa Monica Studio kind of just made that 2018 game again but more. This is a bigger and largely better game than last time around, but almost entirely in ways you would expect going in.

Is it still inherently silly that the former Greek god of war is burning his way through Norse mythology and pretending to have deep feelings about things? Yeah, pretty much. But if that doesn’t bother you, you'll find this to be a satisfying sequel that also acts as a splendid showcase for that $500 box beside your TV.

Piss off a god and find out

God of War Ragnarok screenshot of Freya
'Ragnarok' does right by Freya in a way the last game didn't. Credit: PlayStation

If you played the last God of War game, nothing about the initial setup here will shock you.

A few years have passed since Kratos and Atreus scaled the highest peak in Jötunheim to spread the ashes of the late family matriarch, Faye. As you may recall, they got into some trouble along the way, brutally murdering the progeny of both Freya (Odin’s ex-wife) and Thor (Odin’s son). Not surprisingly, Freya, Thor, and the big dog Odin himself are all pretty pissed about this and want our two heroes to answer for their crimes.

Oh, and Atreus may or may not actually be the mythical figure Loki who, in real-life Norse mythology, turns into a horse and gives birth to another eight-legged horse. (Man, Norse mythology is cool.) Anyway, in the game, he's said to play a massive part in an end-times prophecy. That’s kind of a big deal this time around.

That prophecy manifests as Ragnarok, the fabled Norse apocalypse, forewarned here by a years-long winter that grips all the realms. What was once a low-stakes story about respecting a dead mother’s wishes is now a winding, frost-bitten journey full of pontification about the binding nature of prophecy and the moral cases for and against war. These could be heavy and intriguing themes, but instead they both ring kind of hollow as the story progresses.

There are just too many instances where Kratos and Atreus whine about how they don’t believe in prophecy, only to then voluntarily and knowingly do the exact things they were foretold to do. They'll talk about how they don't want to fight someone they're "supposed" to fight and then fight them anyway because...it's a video game that needs action. All the while, Kratos talks about how undesirable violence is as he rips apart the zombie-like Draugr with his blades.

This hypocrisy is nothing new to video games — the term “ludonarrative dissonance” has been used to describe games that say one thing through the story and then ask players to directly contradict it via gameplay.

God of War Ragnarok screenshot of Ratatoskr
There are some wacky characters to find in the nine realms. Credit: PlayStation

Still, I found myself intrigued by the surface-level machinations of the plot and other character interactions within it. Ragnarok strikes a more jovial tone right away thanks to the inclusion of Mimir, a wise-cracking disembodied head who only became a fixture in the back half of the last game. The goofy dwarven blacksmiths Brok and Sindri are also omnipresent throughout the game, humorously bickering with one another the entire time. 

I’d also like to give special shout-outs to Freya, Thor, and Odin. Last time we saw Freya, she had been reduced to a shrieking mess thanks to Kratos killing her son, but thankfully, we get a much more nuanced version of the character in Ragnarok. She’s got much more skin in the game than Kratos and Atreus due to a longstanding personal grudge against Odin, and she often feels like the true protagonist of the story. As for Odin and Thor, well, the less said the better, but I’ll tell you that Odin acts like a mafia boss and Thor is like his drunken heavy enforcer. It’s a very funny dynamic.

All of these threads eventually pull together for an explosive, fairly awesome finale and an ending that genuinely left me wondering where this story will go next. It’s thematically a little messy with the dissonance between what Kratos says and what he does, but moderately funny dialogue, interesting characters, and great voice acting sell the story anyway.

Axe throwing is still awesome

God of War Ragnarok combat screenshot
The Leviathan Axe is the best. Credit: PlayStation

As for what you actually do in Ragnarok, well, not much has changed since 2018. This is largely the same game, but with enough little improvements and formula shakeups to breathe some new life into the proceedings.

I’ll start with the biggest change of all: You don’t always control Kratos, and you don’t always have Atreus as your companion. Without spoiling things, there are times when the story changes perspective and gives you different companions with different abilities to play with. While nothing is as fun as the traditional Kratos/Atreus combo, I found myself genuinely a little excited every time the player character shifted.

Combat in Ragnarok still feels like a third-person shooter without guns, with the left stick used for moving and strafing, and the right stick used for aiming. You can bash out melee combos with the frosty Leviathan Axe or the scorching Blades of Chaos, or activate different ranged abilities with either weapon. The axe can be thrown and recalled, which is still super satisfying, while the blades can be thrown at and stuck into enemies with an explosive finish. 

There’s also a third weapon I won’t spoil, but it wound up being my favorite of the three. Look forward to that.

God of War Ragnarok combat screenshot
The realms are full of big jerks who want to ruin your day. Credit: PlayStation

You’ll use XP to unlock new skills, some of which can be further modified for increased customization. For example, the Blades of Chaos ranged attack can be upgraded to give Kratos higher defense while he uses it. Gear is also back and just as important as before, as different armor sets grant fun bonuses that let you really go nuts with your builds. I had one build that caused Kratos to stack up poison damage with unarmed attacks and, on top of that, poisoned enemies took increased melee damage. 

Things like that can totally change how you approach encounters and it’s just as fun as it was last time. Aside from occasional character-switching, this is still a game about exploring mostly linear levels that are often about as spacious as a corridor, with the occasional open-ended hub full of side quests showing up to change the flow. When you’re not fighting, you’re solving environmental puzzles, none of which are very hard but some of which at least look cool.

All of this is a good time if you dug what the last game offered, but it won’t change any minds. Maybe I felt this way because I was playing it on a deadline, but the main story is also about 20 percent too long. The third act constantly feels like it’s about to wrap up (you’re literally preparing for an impending apocalyptic war), only to introduce some new, sometimes unrelated problem for Kratos to go solve. I was desperate for it to end for the final five to six hours, even if I enjoyed what was in front of me.

Fetching and familiar

God of War Ragnarok Vanaheim screenshot
Vanaheim is absolutely gorgeous. Credit: PlayStation

Ragnarok’s strict adherence to the conventions of its predecessor extend to the presentation. This game is wickedly gorgeous, with each and every corner of the nine realms bursting with high-resolution detail on PS5. I had fun occasionally just staring at Kratos’ scraggly, disgusting beard because of how lovingly it was rendered. This game also uses the same single-take style as before, meaning there are no hard camera cuts in the entire adventure. 

Regarding the camera, this is a gimmick that I think the series can nix going forward. I love Children of Men’s long takes as much as anyone, but camera cuts don’t detract from the art of cinema; they’re essential to it. Conversation scenes in which the camera just kind of slowly swings from one person to another, instead of cutting between them, are awkward, not inventive.

That gripe aside, it’s just fun to take in each and every realm’s resplendent visual glory. From the frozen wastes of Midgard to the sun-drenched jungles of Vanaheim and the peaceful-yet-sinister fields of Asgard, every area provides a breath of fresh air compared to wherever you happened to be before it. I hammered the PS5 screenshot button while playing Ragnarok.

God of War Ragnarok boat screenshot
Boats are back. Credit: PlayStation

Again, much of what I’ve said here could apply to the last game, too. God of War 2018 was gorgeous, had excellent combat, and was paced and structured in largely the same way. Ragnarok is just a new adventure in the same clothing as before. Its narrative, while inconsistent in its thematic messaging, does enough to pull you in and draw you towards the fireworks at the end.

I’m just never going to buy into this retooled vision of a sad and repentant daddy Kratos — he'll forever be the embodiment of a 12-year-old's video game power fantasy to me.

That said, throwing his axe and recalling it is still a jolly good time. If you felt that way about the last game, go ahead and jump into God of War Ragnarok.

God of War Ragnarok swings its axe onto PlayStation 4 and PlayStation 5 on Nov. 8.

The best early Black Friday pet deals to help you treat your furry friend

Dog with smart collar eating kibble

UPDATE: Nov. 3, 2022, 3:00 p.m. EDT This list has been updated to reflect pricing and availability as of Nov. 3.


Holiday shopping is all about buying gifts for your loved ones, and if your loved ones happen to be cats or dogs, you're in luck. This upcoming Black Friday, we plan on seeing tons of great pet deals, so you'll be able to spoil your furry friend for a bargain this year.

We've already spotted some solid discounts on smart collars, DNA kits, and more, so expect to see lots more pet tech deals as the Black Friday season ramps up. Find all those deals and more below, and be sure to check back on this page often — we'll be updating it regularly with new discounts.

Please note: All newly added deals have been marked with a . Anything with a strikeout was either sold out or no longer available at the sale price as of this writing, but check back often — we're updating this page constantly.

Pet tech deals

Why we love it

Whistle's smart collars all pack in a ton of helpful features, and the Switch is no different. You'll get access to Whistle Health, which allows you to track your pet's health stats and behaviors, as well as accurate GPS services with the ability to mark safe zones. Rest easy knowing that your four-legged bestie is in safe hands.

More pet tech on sale

Pet DNA kit deals

Why we love it

If you want to be more connected to your pet, a DNA kit is a great way to do just that. The Wisdom Panel Premium kit will give you accurate breed testing across over 350 breeds, 210 health tests for genetic risks, and can even help you find your pup's biological family.

More pet DNA kits on sale

Pet bed deals

Why we love it

Let's say you want your dog to be cozy, but you also want their bed to match your stylish home decor. Checking both boxes might sound like a far-off dream, but Paw.com's rug beds actually fit the bill. With a removable, washable cover, memory foam inner, and a design that's meant to look like a decorative rug, these beds are the all-in-one pet product you've been looking for. You can also score up to 50% off nearly every bed on the site ahead of Black Friday.

More pet beds on sale

Deals on pet toys and accessories

Why we love it

If you have a genius dog on your hands, a puzzle toy is one of the best ways to release some of that mental energy. This well-rated Nina Ottosson toy has multiple compartments that hold treats, and your pup will learn to flip, slide, and lift the pieces to reveal their snacks. It's sure to keep boredom at bay, so you can get some work done while your dog plays.

More pet toys and accessories on sale